
Penicillin Cocktail Recipe: Ginger, Honey and a Smoky Scotch Float
Warm ginger, bright lemon and a ribbon of smoky Scotch make the Penicillin the sort of cocktail that feels right when the evenings turn cold. The first sip catches the aroma of the peated whisky; underneath sits a golden, honeyed sour with a lively kick from fresh ginger. You need no specialist glassware beyond a shaker, a strainer and a sturdy tumbler. We’ll show you the exact classic proportions, a homemade syrup that is worth keeping chilled and some useful adjustments if you prefer a gentler or smokier finish.
At a glance
Makes: 1 cocktail. Active time: about 5 minutes once syrup is ready. Syrup: about 10 minutes on the hob plus cooling and optional overnight steep. Glass: rocks / Old Fashioned. Ice: shaker ice and one large fresh cube, or fresh cubes. Equipment: jigger, shaker, strainer, small saucepan, fine sieve, spoon. Style: whisky sour with a smoky float.
The drink contains alcohol. It is for adults; drink responsibly. It is not a treatment or remedy for any illness despite its name.
Jump to the recipe and guide
Summarise this cocktail guide with AI
What is a Penicillin cocktail?
Bartender Sam Ross created the Penicillin at New York’s Milk & Honey in 2005. His starting point was the Gold Rush family of honey-and-lemon whiskey sours, but he added fresh ginger character and a small measure of smoky Scotch on top. Saveur’s July 2026 article confirms Ross’s original experimentation with separately prepared honey syrup and sweetened ginger juice; the combined honey-ginger syrup below is an accessible home version. Difford’s Guide reproduces Ross’s 60 / 22.5 / 22.5 / 7.5 ml original proportions. The name is playful, not a medical claim.
The classic Penicillin: ingredients for one
60 ml blended Scotch whisky, ideally rounded and not aggressively smoky
22.5 ml freshly squeezed lemon juice (about half a medium juicy lemon)
22.5 ml homemade honey-ginger syrup (recipe below)
7.5 ml peated Islay-style Scotch whisky, to float on the finished drink
Plenty of ice to shake; one large fresh cube or several fresh cubes to serve
One small piece of crystallised ginger on a pick, to garnish (optional)
A blended Scotch usually gives the honey, citrus and ginger room to work. For the float choose an expressive peated whisky that you enjoy; even 7.5 ml can be noticeable on the nose. A non-peated alternative is possible, but it loses the aromatic smoke that defines the traditional style.
Make the honey-ginger syrup
For a small batch: 100 g fresh root ginger, peeled and cut into thin slices; 250 ml runny honey; 250 ml water. Put the ginger, honey and water in a small saucepan. Bring just to a gentle boil, turn down the heat and simmer quietly for 5 minutes while stirring until the honey dissolves. Take off the heat and leave to cool. For a more noticeable ginger infusion, cover and refrigerate for about 8–12 hours, then strain well into a clean bottle or jar. Keep refrigerated and use within three days; discard if its appearance or smell changes. This conservative three-day window follows the original preparation published by Difford’s Guide; do not assume that homemade syrup is shelf-stable.
There is no need to boil down to a thick caramel. The point is a pourable syrup with clean ginger aroma and a little heat. You can make it the night before. If you only have 30 minutes, cool and strain sooner, but expect the ginger to be lighter and adjust next time rather than adding raw grated ginger into the finished drink.
Mix, strain and float: four easy steps
Chill the glass. Put one large ice cube or several fresh cubes into a rocks glass, so the served drink is not diluted by tired shaker ice.
Shake with ice. Add 60 ml blended Scotch, 22.5 ml fresh lemon juice and 22.5 ml cooled honey-ginger syrup to a shaker. Fill with ice and shake firmly for about 12–15 seconds, until the outside feels cold.
Strain over fresh ice. Strain into the prepared glass. It should look golden and lightly cloudy, not like a neat whisky.
Float the smoky Scotch and garnish. Measure 7.5 ml peated Scotch. Pour it slowly over the back of a spoon just above the surface of the cocktail or onto the top face of the ice cube. There may not be a permanent razor-sharp visible layer; the aim is to leave aromatic whisky near the top. Add crystallised ginger and serve promptly without a straw if you want to catch more of the peaty aroma.
How the whisky changes the drink
Classic blended Scotch + peated float
60 ml blended Scotch base + 7.5 ml peated Scotch on top. Rounded malt beneath citrus and ginger; smoke at the nose. This follows the documented Penicillin family.
Softer Scotch version
60 ml gentle unpeated blended Scotch base + 5 ml peated whisky on top. A Whisky Clan adjustment, not Sam Ross’s exact ratio; useful if heavy smoke overwhelms you.
Irish whiskey experiment
60 ml blended Irish whiskey base + 7.5 ml peated Scotch on top. The drink may feel lighter or fruitier depending on the whiskey, while the Scotch float still provides smoke. This is a modern creative swap, not an Irish regional tradition or a sensory-test result.
Bourbon experiment
60 ml bourbon base + 7.5 ml peated Scotch on top. Bourbon’s vanilla/caramel-leaning style might accentuate the honey; keep the same lemon and syrup initially, then make adjustments to your preference. Again, a creative variation, not the documented 2005 recipe.
No peated whisky? You can make a lemon, ginger and honey Scotch sour without the float, but it is more accurate to call that a variation rather than the traditional Penicillin.
Small changes that matter
Too sweet? Keep the whisky fixed and try 2.5–5 ml less syrup next time, or a squeeze more lemon. Too sharp? Increase the syrup by about 2.5 ml instead of pouring a large extra measure. Too hot with ginger? Shorten the ginger steep next time rather than trying to filter out flavour after mixing. Too smoky? Reduce the peated float to 5 ml and taste slowly. The float disappears on the surface? That is not necessarily a mistake: temperature, dilution and how gently you pour change the visual separation. A slow pour over a spoon gives you the best chance of keeping the smokier aroma at the top at first.
Serving ideas
Use plenty of cold ice and a chilled glass. Crystallised ginger is the traditional garnish here, but a slim lemon peel can work if that is all you have. For snacks, try a small bite of mature cheddar, salted roasted nuts (allergen warning), or salmon on rye toast to compare bright citrus and gentle smoke. Those are tasting ideas, not tested or traditional combinations. For a non-alcoholic alternative, mix cooled honey-ginger syrup with lemon and sparkling water over ice; leave out every whisky ingredient, and name it a ginger-lemon cooler instead.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a Penicillin different from a Whisky Sour?
It uses honey and ginger as the main sweet-spicy element, then a small peated Scotch float at the end. A classic Whisky Sour does not require either.
Does the peated whisky have to be from Islay?
The classic recipe specifies a peated Islay Scotch. Another peated single malt can be a useful creative substitute, but its flavour and intensity may differ.
Can I make the honey-ginger syrup in advance?
Yes. Refrigerate it in a clean, closed container and use within three days for this home preparation; never treat it as shelf-stable.
Is egg white needed?
No. The Penicillin as documented here is shaken without egg white. Adding it would change the texture and move away from the familiar version.
Why float the smoky Scotch rather than shake it in?
A top measure places more of the smoky aroma near the glass rim for the first sip. It will mix as you drink; the float is about the initial aroma, not a permanent visible layer.
Can I replace Scotch with bourbon or Irish whiskey?
Yes, as a creative riff. Use the same measured base spirit and compare before adjusting honey and lemon. It no longer follows the original Scotch-based construction.
Explore more Whisky Clan cocktails
Sources and artwork credits
Sam Ross original recipe and historical note, reproduced by Difford’s Guide: https://www.diffordsguide.com/cocktails/recipe/2539/penicillin (accessed 19 Nov 2026).
Saveur, Shannon Mustipher, updated 3 July 2026, history and accessible homemade syrup: https://www.saveur.com/article/recipes/penicillin-scotch-cocktail/ (accessed 19 Nov 2026).
Malts GB, producer recipe and practical 50/12.5/25/20 ml alternative: https://www.malts.com/en-gb/recipes/penicillin (accessed 19 Nov 2026).
Liquor.com Penicillin recipe and technique: https://www.liquor.com/recipes/penicillin/ (accessed 19 Nov 2026).
Men’s Journal interview quoting Sam Ross on the whisky float: https://www.mensjournal.com/drink/penicillin-cocktail (accessed 19 Nov 2026).
Artwork: original AI-assisted watercolour-style illustration of the cocktail and ingredients, branded with an existing genuine Whisky Clan round logo image and separate FJ signature. A drawn impression rather than a photograph or physically tested serve. The documented original recipe and history are distinguished from Whisky Clan's suggested whisky variations; no tasting panel was conducted.





Comments